‘You’re a disgrace, PTA….Hassan Kamal Wattoo
THERES a certain amount of heartache thats intrinsic to living in a place like Pakistan. If youre paying any attention, youll see decisions so self-defeating as to be psychotic. Youll see poor economic performance peel back the bare necessities people need to survive. Youll see the state spend billions on plots and protocols for its richest citizens anyway. Youll see powerful people murder weak ones. Youll see the legal system let them get away with it.
And once all that is done, and every misery imaginable has been inflicted en masse, youll see those in power look at whatever tiny joys regular people are left with in their lives, and manically, sadistically, youll see them try and snatch those away too.
Last week, a country of 220 million lost access to the largest free repository of knowledge on the planet. Suddenly, the first result to almost everything on Google led to a black screen. Millions of kids doing homework and class projects across the country were left without answers. A window to the outside world closed shut, an immeasurable amount of curiosity left unsatiated. Anywhere else in the world, youd think this was an elaborate cyberattack aimed at crippling a generation, ensuring they can never compete on the global stage. But really, no amount of foreign conspiracies can come close to the damage dealt by our own limitless stupidity.
The Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA) banned Wikipedia on Saturday last week. By Monday, and only after the prime ministers intervention, the ban was lifted. No specific reasoning was offered for the decision. No apology after its reversal. Enough laws were broken, and constitutional rights violated, that Id need a whole other column just to list them out. How then, did this regulator get away with a stupidly illegal move, only to pretend it never happened?
How many success stories did we undo?
Well, its got experience. PTAs greatest hits include blocking Facebook in 2010, YouTube in 2012, the video game PUBG in 2020, and social media app TikTok that same year. All these bans were reversed. But every time, the damage was done.
Consider YouTube, which stayed banned in Pakistan for four years. Since then, its grown to contribute over a billion dollars and 750,000 jobs to the Indian economy. Regular people found a following, monetised their creativity, and turned into stars overnight. Google set up domestic offices. Lives changed. And because countries like India and Bangladesh had not convinced the world that their technological decisions were made by a cabal of suicidal chimpanzees, foreign investment grew exponentially.
How many success stories did we undo with that single ban? How many people are there in poverty today who would have been lifted out of it by investments that would have flowed in if not for PTAs incompetence?
Consider PUBG. Ive never played the game myself. But basic empathy means recognising that something could mean nothing to me and the world to someone else. In the most remote, rural parts of Pakistan, TikTok has become a source of happiness and entertainment for people with very little of it to go around. So, if something brings people joy, harms no one, and breaks no laws, who am I to take it away? How could I be so arrogant as to assume I know whats better for them?
The fact that a regulator routinely exercises this arrogance, has it blow up in its face every time, and does not respect its people enough to apologise for each fresh display of incompetence, is an insult to all of us.
While writing this, I spoke to PTA insiders on the condition of anonymity. Responses were similar: its not really their fault, its the pressure from the maulvis. But Im sorry to break it to you; Pakistani taxpayers dont pay you to sacrifice their freedoms at the altar of your cowardice. If you dont have the guts to do your job with integrity, and in the interest of the people you serve, resign.
In the meantime, decisions that impact every Pakistani must be debated by elected representatives parliament. PTA operates under the federal government, which holds the power to cut it down to size and prevent further self-sabotage.
If the folks at PTA (many of whom may indeed be well-intentioned cogs in an undeniably destructive machine) see this column for what it is (a sincere appeal to stop hurting our country), I hope theyll engage with it. Write a response. Justify their decisions. And if they cant do that, Im sure they can take responsibility for their mistakes; pledge to do better in the future.
But judging by their history, they wont do that either. Judging by PTAs history, dear reader, once this column inevitably lands on his desk, a powerful man in Islamabad will put down his paper, take a sip of his tea, and turn to address his subordinates. Is there any way we can ban this guy too?
The writer is a lawyer and columnist from Okara, based in Islamabad.
Twitter: @hkwattoo1
Courtesy Dawn, February 12th, 2023