Not another Egypt, please!…. Dr Muhammad Ali Ehsan

Egypt, like Pakistan, is a recipient of IMF loan and holds external debts and liabilities of $155 billion. Pakistans external debt is also huge, amounting closer to $126 billion. Today, over 30 per cent of Egypts population lives under the poverty line. In Pakistan, poverty is graded somewhere between 35 to 40 per cent. These figures are important to share, as twelve years ago a story began in Egypt a story which is quite similar to what is happening in Pakistan today. Why must this story be told? It must be told because its a story in which the will of the people was subdued and what transpired was the creation of a political system that was a continuation of the old one in which anti status quo forces were defeated and status quo prevailed. From this story of recent past, we must draw some lessons, the biggest of them all is that despite the removal of the only civilian President in 2013 (Mohammed Morsi ruled Egypt for one year from 2012 to 2013) and his replacement by another military President Fattah El Sisi, Egypt has continued to go down the path of external borrowing, poverty and external debt. Should we choose to take the same path?

In 2013 in Egypt, it was the military versus the Muslim Brotherhood. Just a year earlier, Morsi became a candidate for Presidency on peoples support having defeated a military candidate for presidency on a narrow but decisive margin. Hardly six months into his presidency Morsi made constitutional amendments that showcased him as power seeking, power accumulating President, a bad president who was becoming authoritative and dictatorial. The military responded by opposing him and broadcasting a message on state television giving Morsi 48 hours to respond to military and peoples demand and step down as President. The military propagated that if Morsi was left in office, Egypt will become another Somalia and experience a civil war. To add pressure, the Headquarters of the Muslim Brotherhood was burnt and looted within hours of this military announcement.

President Morsi rejected the offer and posted a message on YouTube that he was ready to sit and engage and talk with anyone. That message was also taken off the YouTube. His supporters turned out in numbers to conduct marches and arrange large sit-ins to support him; they pitched tents, blocked roads and vouched to stay put until military went back to barracks and President Morsis government was restored. Then came one of the blackest days of modern Egyptian history. Egyptian security forces massacred over 800 civilians mostly in Cairos Rabaa Square as people gathered there to protest against the military coup of July 2013. This in recent history is considered as the largest killing of demonstrators in a single day. President Morsi was removed and imprisoned. Faced with multiple criminal charges and death sentence the former president kept appearing in the Egyptian courts until June 2019 when during one of the appearances in the court he collapsed and died. President Morsi was an educated man; in fact he was an engineer who got his education from the United States. It was President Morsi who appointed General Sisi as the Commander of Egyptian Armed Forces not knowing that he was appointing not only a new sheriff of the town but also the new law who less than a year later will replace him as President.

Egyptians had long hoped for true democracy and after the removal of President Hosni Mubarak during the Arab Spring it finally seemed that Egypt will take that road but it didnt. The six-week long sit-in by people that supported President Morsi was brought to an end by brutal and merciless killing. The demand for President Morsis resignation had culminated into a coup but before that there was one month state of emergency declared in the country which was extended further to two months. In 2014, General Sisi removed his uniform and became the President. He even won a greater majority of votes 97% to be re-elected as President in 2018 for a period of six years.

Under President Sisi, many people who participated in pro-Morsi demonstrations and riots are still behind bars. At least 75 people have been sentenced to death. Not a single member of security forces has so far been held responsible for the brutal murder and killing of over 800 people (Muslim Brotherhood claims 2,000 people killed by security forces). Ten years later, today the Muslim Brotherhood is an outlawed, banned organisation that is declared terrorist. President Sisi rules with impunity yet the lives of the Egyptian people have not turned for better.

When Hosni Mubarak was removed after a prolonged rule of 30 years, the Egyptians had thought that if Mubarak could go then it was time for dictatorship to finally end; and when Morsi became the first civilian President, the people of Egypt were dreaming modern democracy. That the democracy would be sidelined so soon no one had imagined. Egypts experiment with democracy is termed slow speed crash as everyone could see it happening but nobody could stop it. When two parties fight one way of figuring out who is fighting for the just cause is to measure the moral ground on which they stand. Measuring moral ground is simple the values that one believes in must match the actions on ground. If there is a disconnect between both then you are not standing on the moral ground.

The despotic rule of President Sisi has given only one thing back to the Egyptians once again ruled by a military President. Egypt is under debt; it is poor and it struggles to live up to its great civilisational potential. It is hoped that Pakistan doesnt take Egypts route for we have our constitution and democratic values. As long as we live up to them and they show in our actions we may evolve into something better than what we are today. We want to be a shackled state not despotic and by no means an absent state.

Courtesy  The Express Tribune, May 21st, 2023.