Can Xi help bring peace to Ukraine?…… Shazia Anwer Cheema

When Chinese President Xi Jinping was leaving his country for Kremlin, he called his three-day visit to Russia that started on March 20, 2023 a visit for peace. Both sides discussed bilateral and regional issues including Ukraine. President Xi said, China has upheld an objective and impartial position based on the issues merits and actively promoted peace talks. And President Vladimir Putin said, We are grateful for Chinas balanced line regarding the events in Ukraine, we welcome Chinas willingness to play a constructive role in resolving the crisis.

In binary opposition to that, the West is skeptical that China has any role to play on the Ukraine war. Western media is debating that China is roleplaying America by pretending that it has the same influential leverage the US has been enjoying for decades.

Another notion circulating in the West is: if China somehow makes possible any kind of ceasefire between Russia and Ukraine, will that even be acceptable? I believe capping a conflict must be the top priority for everybody because wars and conflicts bring nothing but destruction, and Ukraine has been paying too heavy a price since 2014, with the previous year being horrific.

According to a report released on March 13, 2023 by OHCHR, 21,965 civilian casualties including 8,231 killed and 13,734 injured occurred in Ukraine from 24 February 2022 to 12 March 2023. If we talk about overall conflicts where the West was a partner, the number is touching over a million. A report by the Watson Institute for International and Public Affairs of Brown University claims that over 929,000 people have died in the post-9/11 wars either due to direct war violence or consequences of war in Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria and Yemen and the impact of the Afghan war on neighbouring Pakistan. The Brown University Project Cost of War indicates abovementioned wars produced 38 million refugees and displaced persons. These figures are enough to understand that any chance to cap conflict in Ukraine must be taken as an opportunity whether it comes from China or from Saudi Arabia which has also offered to play a role over the Ukraine conflict.

Chinas 12-point plan to end the Ukraine conflict is not received well by the West. The NATO secretary general believes China lacks credibility as it did not condemn the illegal invasion of Ukraine and, together with Russia, signed an agreement of limitless partnership just days before the Ukraine war.

Political analyst Andrew KP Leung says China follows its ancient philosophy of limitless partnership for accepting the greys in relationship, unlike the West. He insists China is more receptive to mutual interests on case to case basis and not in a holistic way; and China believe in the all enemy or all friends scenario but rather dwells on working relationships.

Chinese media builds a narrative that the West is fueling the Ukraine conflict and China is trying to cool it down. Though the Ukraine war is tiresome for the West, especially for the US which is facing economic recession, it is not easy for the West to accept Chinese mediation because it can harm established rhetoric of bully, imperial, dictator, hegemonic, etc for articulating Russia and China.

Chinas 12-point proposal includes respecting the sovereignty of all countries; abandoning the Cold War mentality; stopping unilateral sanctions; ceasing hostilities; resuming peace talks; resolving the humanitarian crisis; protecting civilians and POWs; keeping nuclear power plants safe; reducing strategic risks; facilitating grain exports; keeping industrial supply chains stable; and promoting post-conflict reconstruction. The first three points look strange in western perspective, as they can be strategic issues for the West.

However, I believe these three are unattainable goals, as the world has seen that the definition of a sovereign country is always self-serving and meddling in internal matters by using Cold War mentality has not worked either. Also, the world has always seen sanctions on a unilateral basis that are always portrayed as multilateral. Maybe time has come to abandon the fixed trajectories of black and white and move forward to embrace grey areas.

Courtesy The Express Tribune, March 25th, 2023.